7 Comments
User's avatar
The Village Idiwitt's avatar

To wit, I cannot help but think of the poor, innocent, dead victims of Russian aggression, I mean Putin’s willing executioners, and slaughtered Isrealis in cold blood, with extreme prejudice, by Haniyeh’s very willing and very sadistic Mohammedans (Don’t be lie ve me, you could have live streamed it it like so many Palestinian’s did on the atrocity of October 7th because the so called occupied KNEW it was coming to a teenage concert near them!!! And I cannot help but wonder how the fa the Horseshoe Theory became true…When it comes to love and war you have more in common with that Frrr Carlson and R.F.K.j. than you do with the truth about war and peace…Don’t believe me Gardner, you are literally a mass murdering dict tator, dictator for life Vlad the Impalers best spokesperson broadcasting live from a so called church that will never be burned downed thanks to the U.S. military. That is a fact, not an opinion. Alls the Russian military has to do is turn around and the human scum that deserves 100 percent of their collective suffering has to do is surrender and return the innocent human beings they kidnapped that many, many, many a so called innocent Palestinian KNOWS where they are still be held (and tortured) in captivity. Death to tyrants like Putin, Death to jihadists…oh, and God bless the U.S.A. and Viva Israel. W.T.F. Gardner you should thank the God who supposed believe in that you were not born under actual tyrants like Brezhnez, or Arafat….may both be rotting in hell, as with anyone and everyone who would blame America for the Eurasia or the Middle East’s being the underworld

Expand full comment
Gardner Goldsmith's avatar

Did you see what the US military did to the Branch Davidians? Your history not only lacks credible links to reality, you could help your argument by tracing to root morality and ethics, the foundation of Natural Rights and free will. Those are much more powerful bulwarks than arguments that depend on info that has been debunked. Please recall that the instigators of the Israeli occupation force us to pay for it. Is it too much to be asked to be left alone in this, the so-called "land of the free"?

Expand full comment
The Village Idiwitt's avatar

Hi Gardner,

Thanks for your comments on my comments…I guess. I endeavor to make you think a second time, and to even better, make you laugh. Respectfully, as God is our witness, you have utterly failed in doing the former and you inadvertently succeed in making me unfortunately laugh out loud proving Perry Farrell’s lament “Nothing’s Shocking”. But unlike you, I will address each and every nonsensical word to your non response to my absolute truism how lucky you are to be born in the U.S.A. ..and not in the mass murderous dictatorships of Brezhnev and Arafat..that literally spawned equally murderous peace and love, I mean literal warlords Putin and Haniyeh…as your liberal graffiti arts history not only lacks credible links to reality, your vile and contemptible stupid arguments completely ignore the facts as to why there are hundreds of thousands of marauding Russians in Ukraine and why thousands of Hamas invaded Israel.. Hence your history, I mean bogus retort makes no mention of a dict tator for life Putin or irreligious Mohammedans Haniyeh…anymore than some Austrian turd ever named names that stabbed the German people in the back because, hint hint, I should not have to tell a conspiracy believer like you, such Jooozes (hat tip Jonah Goldberg) literally never existed. And like Germany of the 20’s and 30’s, the Russian and Palestinians peoples problems and the highway to hell they are mutually engaged upon are their collective own sorry ass faults…Not the jooozes, you mean Netanyahu’s. Seriously,shame the f on you Gardner, speaking of morality and ethics, let alone even you should be able to admit Putin and his fellow warmongering Haniyeh have absolutely, positively ZERO respect for Natural rights or free will. Don’t believe me, move to either of their criminal fiefdoms…unlike the so called church you broadcast from or anywhere you want to broadcast your beliefs in Israel. Mind you, even you honestly can admit you debunked nothing in my actual arguments I espoused to your disliking, anymore than the U.S. military had anything to do with Koreshians demise…I know it was a little wacked out cult in the middle of nowhere’sville Texas plain that the FBI raided…but any honest arbiter of your argument would tell you Gardner, whoever, or whatever you blame for a little house on the prairie going up in flames has absolutely, positively nothing to do with anything I said or was responding to you about in the first place. Just as…no one is leaving…you alone when you shit on the land of the free, as I don’t deny you the right to free speech and will not hesitate to tell you you are wrong….liberty…conspiracy…lover. Again, thank the God you supposedly believe in Gardner you were born in the U.S.A. and not in a plots of land run by actual warmongering scum of earth that would not hesitate to stop your breathing if you dared disagree with them on the public airwaves, let alone put anything disagreeable with their mass murdering regimes in print.

Expand full comment
Gardner Goldsmith's avatar

I hope you are aware of the historical facts that the US military killed nearly 80 innocent people in Waco, and the attacks were funded by additional government aggression threatened against taxpayers to fund what is supposed to be a government constrained by the US Constitution, which does not allow any of what the Clinton Administration did there. I also hope that you are aware of the fact that it is documented that the US and Israel made sure Hamas was funded by your tax dollars. I also hope you acknowledge that your comments verge on aggressive, even in our exchanges. That is unacceptable. If you would like to debate this on my program and can be civil, perhaps you would like to come on live with me to discuss ethics, Natural Rights, and free will. The mercurial nature of your messages here indicates to me that you might be an engaging conversationalist, but I worry that you would reduce your argument to contradictory statements and ad hominem. I brought up Waco because you mentioned churches, and you might also want to look into two things. First, the US has backed al Nusra and ISIS, which, like Israel, have systematically destroyed numerous Christian sites and killed many Christians in the Middle East. My concern is not isolated to the welfare of Christians, but I mention it to ask you to recall those facts, and, second, your approach to statism seems to be automatic acceptance of the enslavement of your neighbor. That is immoral. Statism is immoral. It is predicated on aggression. I hope that any further posts you make here are more civil and based on fundamental ethics, reduce the double-sided nature of your positions, and do not assume for your neighbor that it is okay to take his money to kill innocent people. As far as me being "lucky" not to have been born elsewhere, you could apply the same euphemism to not having been born a Palestinian in Gaza and then imprisoned by the US-funded occupying forces of Israel without trial. There are plenty of evildoers in all of those regions, but the Palestinians are not the decades-long aggressors. That is why the place is called Occupied Gaza. It's occupied by a lawless nation-state that unconstitutionally and immorally receives my tax money. The predicate of government taking my money to fund anything is unsound. That moral baseline stands. No one need try to layer gauze over it by claiming the Palestinians are wicked or that Russia is filled with evil people that, for some reason, makes it okay to engage in the evil of taking my money and enslaving me to combat them. And, by the way, it has not been Russia that engaged in the overthrow of Ukraine, nor was it Russia that expanded NATO past what Baker promised in the 1990s. The sweep of Nazis into the lands of the Donbass is also not the fault of Putin or innocent people in Russia or the Donbass or Crimea. Your argument is ethically unsound and historically flawed, but those are things that people can reasonably discuss. If you continue to engage in ad hominem and petulant written attacks, that is unacceptable, and not only harms one's argument, it risks making the source of the rhetoric and attacks seem as if he is too easily angered to be worth engaging on a regular basis. I hope that offers some of my perspective on exchanges in general, and your messages here, in particular. Take care.

Expand full comment
The Village Idiwitt's avatar

Fascinating. I get you do not get my sense of humor, as your are as die hard fundamentalist, as any Mohammedan willing Haniyeh executioner…but me should like to think you can take a joke, even when the Liberdopian frat house you broadcast is the butt of it…Unlike the seventh century Stoneage Romeos (loved the album when I was a kid, but have to admit, grew out of my gurus phase, with all due respect to Rand) that you grotesquely, immorally defend for engaging in mass murder on the atrocity of October 7th, who no more respect your natural rights and ethics anymore than Gaza was occupied by the jooozes, I mean Israel, on October 6th…Anymore, than NATO, or the now 1 MILLLLLION plus Ukrainian casualties were threatening a mass murderer and war criminal’s Putin’s neo-international socialist, retrograde, Soviet Russian Empire. Dishearteningly and shamefully you blame the jooozes, I mean Netanyahu’s, I mean America first, for gangster’s aggression, then have the audacity of dope to lament about my tone. I have always liked listening to you Gardner, and not having heard you for years, thought you had finally grown up and become wise to escape the orbit of that estate tax evading Minister Freeman and his clever flock of New Imp Shire Ian Stooges (get it Gardner…pronounced NICES’!) are New Englands version of degenerates. At least, unlike their fellow their middle eastern radical agenda counterparts the born and bred American apostates actually do shoot to kill anyone and everyone that does not have it their way. So, I digress, as my poking fun of you is in direct response to your words, on and off the public airwaves. Just as I do not mince words, given your very public political rhetoric, you should thank whatever god it is you say you believe in stuck between your two ears that I do not know or have loved any victim of Putin or Allahs very willing executioners. Where you get such nonsense as “your history” explains your incredible link suggesting the U.S. military, not the ATF and FBI…oh, wait, I get it, it is a distinction without a difference, burned down the little Waco house on a prairie (Hmmn, no mention of the cult demonic sex god Koresh being at all to blame…as you will hear gno defense of the Nine Inch Nails torture chamber the “compound”was turned into… let alone my defend the ridiculous ATF military junta siege in the first place ...For as horrific an overkill and criminal atrocity Witt called the Wacko raid at the time, 80 innocent dead (Does that include David, Gardner!?) is what the Russian military and Hamas barbarians believe doing for their evil masters before you wake and bake, I mean make breakfast call a good days start to spreading their evil idiotologies. But speaking of your constitutional belief in anti christianism, I mean anti statism, can you at least please apply the same such powerful logic of yours to the new and improved KGB apparatchik and Yasser Arafat children of a lesser god for being born, bred and raised to kill for their masters enemies, aka Ukrainians and Jooozes…And, wait, wait don’t tell me that fail to live up to their professed constitutions…unless your going to cite the communist manifesto and The Hadith. Again, you blame me, I mean America first, for all the bad things your mom and dad did, I mean the U.S. military, and make no mention of the good (sure beats being born in East Germany or North Korea doesn’t Gardner!?)….You fault NOT communism or Islamism that literally, and gravely, unfortunately still pervade and misrule gigantic landmasses on Earth… since long before you were lucky enough to even be born in the U.SA. Putin and Hamas should be so lucky the U.S. military do NOT occupy Moscow or Jerusalem. But, in the meantime can we both at least bow our collective heads and hope and pray as many American made full metal jackets enter the depraved skulls of Putins willing Russians…And Hamas and Hezbollah are not anti Israel because Israel occupied Gaza Gardner…Their seventh century war profiteer Muhammad and his nickname Allah is the one and only God jackwads that committed the atrocity of October 7th…the same one that bears no competition or contradiction and is anti Israel because, like Russia, the Palestinians live in a one party state by hammer and sic….literally. No wonder they hate Jooozes that pray to a differing book…just like, to use an American historical parallel, southern man literally had to be reminded what their good book said, I should NOT have to remind you Gardner what the “grotesque plagiary of the Old and New Testament’s “ (hat tip Hitch) has to say about dem joozes, and what the Hadith says about infidels should erased from impolite society…What choice does Israel have in the face of such…aggression…Gardner!?.…The very people’s who you make an offense of, I mean defense, do not respect your right to life, liberty or the pursuit of happiness in the first place. And you have the audacity of dope to call my arguments ethically unsound and historically flawed. Putin and Haniyeh both thought Stalin and Arafat were really cool, not to mention right for being mass murderers. And again, you will blame America first for them picking up the mantle of their heroes. Shame on you Gardner. Lucky for you the man ain’t gonna cap you for speaking out against him from so called church. Speaking of being aggressive…Gotta run on. I have barely the time in an off day to even address most of your deeply offensive nonsense penned above. But let me put it another way that would cost me my life east of the Ukraine or East of Israel jus for saying it out loud. Death to Putin. Allah is NOT God. Muhammad was a war profiteer. Death to Jihadists

Expand full comment
Gardner Goldsmith's avatar

Thank you for revealing your continued pattern of ad hominem, and not addressing replies to what you put forward as points. Your lengthy message meanders through a series of contradictions, engages in what you said I did, which is bearing false witness, claiming that I defend the mass murder on Oct 7, and more. Those are erroneous and potentially defamatory statements. You also do not address the fact that the state, itself, is a form of aggression, forcing me and others who do not want to be involved to, in the end, fund this or be imprisoned. You brought up churches, you still have not addressed the fact that the US military and FBI killed innocent people in Waco, no trial, nothing, including kids, using tax dollars to do so. You defame my parents. Your inability to stay on target is one thing, but your repeated forays into abusive language run the risk of seeing you banned at Substack. Your claim to be utilizing a sense of humor does not accommodate for contradictory statements, a lack of candor, and a faulty grasp of history and interpersonal ethics. It also does not dilute or excuse an increasingly insulting series of brickbats. I no longer will engage you in this thread. Your statist position has seen you overlook salient points, seemingly accept the federal US government illegally attacking people and killing them in TX (no trials, completely contrary to the so-called rules of the Constitution) and excuse the immoral seizure of my neighbor's money to send weapons all around the world, including to an artificial nation-state created by western powers that has no tie to the people who live there. You have not addressed the expansion of NATO contrary to US promises, the US involvement with Nazis and overthrow of Ukraine using our money, and more. These are things which, under the false paradigm of the US government, we as those the government threatens, must fund or flee. Purportedly, "we" control the US government, not Russia, and the US government funds NATO, funds Ukraine, overthrew the elected government there, and continues to give them weapons, even as the government bans religions. These are things to which the US government has tied us, just like it has tied us to the IDF, Hamas, and those who killed people in Waco. They are not mundane or small things to consider, and should not be conflated with disputes one might have with Russian policy. These are policies which we, as subjects of the US empire, might be forced to fund. As I mentioned, regardless of what one thinks of the Israeli occupation, at least one might hope you would acknowledge the moral primacy of being left out of that conflict and not being forced to pay for either side, the IDF, or Hamas. Thank you. Please refrain from your ad hominem messages if you decide to respond. If you want to debate this on camera, on my live program, let me know. I will discontinue responses to you here because your messages are not humorous, are indefensible, and repeatedly wander into harridan-like attacks lacking direction or moral or ethical validity.

Expand full comment
The Village Idiwitt's avatar

“I will no longer engage you on this thread “…only to have so much more to have to get of your chest about what I had to say, you repeated the sentiment down the paragraph. But I mean it sincerely, or “No joke” as our doddering do.t lord man still hiding in the White House likes to , I do appreciate the attempt at dialogue, as you repeat your deeply, deeply, deeply offense immoral sentiments blaming NATO for a war criminals mass murder in Ukraine,(just who are you calling Nazi Gardner) and you blame the Joozes, I mean Netanyahu for the Palatinian scum (and yes, most Palestinians thought October 7th was really cool, therefore they are scum by definition…and you blame the joozes for their fate…again shame the fa on you Gardner …who, by the way, were NOT occupied in Gaza on October 6th, unlesss, if you are being factually correct In referring to the stoneage romeos “Hamas”j. And And again, “just to be clear”, my mention of a “chirch” was in direct reference to Ian and Marks real estate tax haven your show broadcast out of…and clearly, oh, wait I guess it was not clear to you, nothing in my original comments have anything to do with what happened to a little cult hous e on a prairie over thirty years ago…but you being such a die hard true believer in the ludicrous philosophical fallacy Taxiation is theft, therefore anyone that disagrees with Gardner is immoral is no way to conduct a philosophy debate Garder, as No philosophy teacher of yours would disagree with Witt about my take down of your fundamentalist beliefs in the first place.

It’s hard to respond to your rants as you don’t get mine because you literally think, like Mohammedans that you have a monopoly on morality and ethics. Don’t believe me, listen to yo7r show…of which, I was most respectful and engaging for over two hous one date that shall live in infamy (sorry you don’t get I most definitely was not making fun of your mommy and daddy, but you…can’t take a joke, than stop calling into your own show 🤪🍺✌️

Expand full comment